Best Herbalife Butterfinger Shake Recipe

If you are looking for Herbalife Butterfinger Shake Recipe then you are on the right blog page. In this post, I have tried to make the Best Herbalife Butterfinger Shake Recipe with some useful information that you will like a lot I hope.

Herbalife Butterfinger Shake Recipe
Herbalife Butterfinger Shake Recipe

what is Herbalife Butterfinger shake?

Herbalife Butterfinger Shake is a tasty and nutritious beverage created by blending specific Herbalife products. It’s a popular choice, known for its rich and delightful flavor.

To make this shake, start with 8 oz of water and add Herbalife’s Cookies and Cream Formula 1, Dulce de Leche (Delicious Formula 1), and Chocolate Protein. For an extra touch, you can include Peanut Butter. Blend it all, ensuring full scoops for maximum benefits.

The result is a thick and delicious Butterfinger Shake. It’s a satisfying drink that’s gained popularity, especially for those looking to enjoy a flavorful treat while still getting essential nutrients.

The Ingredients & Tools Needs For Herbalife Butterfinger Shake

The ingredients and Tools are as follows:


Water: You will need 8 oz of fresh water to make this shake.

Cookies and Cream Formula 1: You will need 2 scoops of Cookies and Cream Formula 1. Use Herbalife Formula 1 Nutritional Shake Mix, Cookies, and Cream to make this shake.

Dulce de Leche: You will need 1 scoop of Dulce de Leche. Use Herbalife Formula 1 Shake Mix-Dulce de Leche to make this shake.

Chocolate Protein: You will need 2 scoops of Chocolate Protein. Use Herbalife Protein Drink Mix Chocolate or you can use Whey Protein Powder.

Herbalife Butterfinger Shake Recipe Ingredients
Herbalife Butterfinger Shake Recipe Ingredients

Peanut Butter: You will need 1 scoop of Peanut Butter. Use Happy Belly brand peanut butter or use what you have on hand.

Ice cubes: You will need some good quality ice cubes.

Equipment & Tools:

You will need an Electric Blender, Measuring Cup, Measuring Scoop, and Serving Glass.

So, let’s see How To Make the Herbalife Butterfinger Shake Recipe at Home!

Herbalife Butterfinger Shake Recipe

Herbalife Butterfinger Shake Recipe

Josephen & Animash
Follow this Herbalife Butterfinger Shake Recipe ingredients and directions to make the perfect Herbalife Butterfinger Shake like a professional mixologist.
No ratings yet
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 0 minutes
Total Time 5 minutes
Course Drinks
Cuisine American
Servings 1

Equipment & Tools

  • Electric Blender
  • Measuring Cup
  • Measuring Scoop
  • Serving Glass



  • Start by adding 8 ounces of water to your blender. Pour the liquid first to avoid sticking.
  • Add two scoops of Cookies and Cream Formula 1.
  • Follow it up with one scoop of Dulce de Leche (Delicious Formula 1).
  • Now, add two scoops of Chocolate Protein.
  • Add one scoop of Peanut Butter for that extra flavor.
  • Blend all the ingredients until smooth.
  • To make it refreshing, toss in some ice cubes and blend again.
  • Add some crushed real Butterfinger on top for that authentic touch.
  • Pour the thick and delicious shake into your glass.
  • Finish it off with a drizzle of Dulce de Leche on top.
  • And there you have it – the Butterfinger Shake! Thick, nutritious, and absolutely delicious.


Serving: 1glass
Tried This Recipe?Let Us Know How It Was & Give Ratings.

Our Other Drink Recipes:

Variations & Tips For Herbalife Butterfinger Shake Recipe


Fruity Twist: Add a handful of your favorite berries or sliced banana to the blender for a fruity kick. It adds a refreshing twist to the Butterfinger Shake.

Nut Lovers Delight: If you’re a fan of nuts, throw in a handful of almonds or walnuts. It not only adds crunch but also introduces a nutty flavor that complements the sweetness.

Mocha Madness: For coffee enthusiasts, mix in a shot of espresso or a teaspoon of instant coffee. This variation gives your Butterfinger Shake a delightful mocha flavor.


Smooth Blend: Always pour the liquid (water) first before adding the powders. This ensures a smoother blend and prevents sticking to the blender.

Ice Control: Adjust the amount of ice cubes based on your preference. More ice cubes make it colder and thicker, while fewer cubes result in a creamier texture.

Top it Right: Experiment with toppings! Whether it’s a sprinkle of cinnamon, a dollop of whipped cream, or extra crushed Butterfinger on top, get creative with the finishing touches for added flair.

what to serve with Herbalife Butterfinger shake?

Pair your Herbalife Butterfinger Shake with simple snacks or light meals to create a satisfying and balanced eating experience.

Consider having a piece of whole-grain toast with peanut butter, a small bowl of mixed fruits, or a handful of nuts. These options provide a mix of fiber, healthy fats, and additional nutrients to complement the shake.

Toast With Peanut Butter For Herbalife Butterfinger Shake
Toast With Peanut Butter For Herbalife Butterfinger Shake

You can also enjoy your shake alongside a yogurt parfait with granola or a small serving of cottage cheese with sliced vegetables. Keep it light and nutrient-packed to enhance the overall goodness of your Herbalife Butterfinger Shake.

Our Other Drinks Recipe:

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use water alternatives in the shake?

Yes, you can use milk or a dairy-free alternative if you prefer. Adjust based on your taste and dietary choices.

Are there other flavor options for Formula 1 besides Cookies and Cream?

Absolutely! Herbalife offers various flavors, so feel free to experiment. Dulce de Leche and Chocolate are used in this recipe, but you can try others too.

Can I skip the Peanut Butter for a lighter option?

Of course! Peanut Butter is optional. If you want a lighter shake, you can leave it out or adjust the quantity to your liking.

How do I make the shake less thick or more refreshing?

Simply reduce the amount of ice cubes or water for a lighter consistency. Play around with the ingredients to suit your preferences.

Are there alternatives to the suggested toppings?

Certainly! Get creative with toppings. Whipped cream, a sprinkle of cinnamon, or even extra crushed Butterfinger can add unique touches.

Can I make this shake without a blender?

While a blender provides the best consistency, you can use a shaker bottle. Ensure thorough mixing for a smooth result.

Our Other Drinks Recipe:


Herbalife Butterfinger Shake is a tasty and nutritious treat that’s easy to make. With simple steps and a blend of Herbalife products, it offers a thick and delicious beverage. The shake is versatile, allowing for personalization with variations like adding fruits or nuts. It’s a fantastic option for those seeking a flavorful yet health-conscious drink.

Remember to experiment with toppings and enjoy it with light snacks for a balanced experience. Whether you’re into fitness or just looking for a delightful treat, then this Herbalife Butterfinger Shake is a great choice, bringing together taste and nutrition in one satisfying sip.

Spread the love

Leave a Comment

Recipe Rating